Pass the Chalice?

"Bishops defying swine flu advice" said the headlines recently.

Some bishops in England  have recently reinstated using a shared chalice to distribute
communion wine. UK Dept of Health advice is to suspend this practice during the swine
flu outbreak to prevent the spread of this disease. I can see why chalices were identified as potentially spreading
infections but church goers should take heart because drinking wine from a
shared  silver communal vessel may be safer than sharing a cup of water.

Why?

Wine kills disease-causing bacteria and viruses. Wine or beer was drunk in
the past in
preference to water when water supplies were suspect. Our ancestors knew from
trial and error that these drinks were safer. Its not just the
alcohol that can kill bacteria and viruses, phenolic compounds in wine such as resveratrol
do so as well. There is a lot of research examining this topic at the moment. I
found one very speculative paper listed on Global
Health
database that suggests resveratrol could be used as part of a
treatment for flu in the absence of other treatments. 

The chalices themselves may also play a part. They are often made of silver
and this also kills bacteria. Silver coated instruments are widely used in hospitals to prevent
infections and silver impregnated fabrics are being investigated as well for use
in dressings and in disinfectants. 

I don't know if the combined effects of the wine and the silver are enough to prevent
diseases spreading from communion chalices but they could reduce it. There is evidence that
some bacteria do survive on chalices used in Church. I found a study listed
on Global Health that examined 15 chalices and found slightly more
than a quarter of them had contamination with disease causing bacteria. Nevertheless the
study concluded that chalices are reasonably safe if you are healthy. 

Some reading:

Infection from the communion cup: an underestimated risk? Fiedler, K.;
Lindner, M.; Edel, B.; Wallbrecht, F.; Zentralblatt für Hygiene und
Umweltmedizin, 1998, 201, 2, pp 167-188,

Inhibitory
activity of diluted wine on bacterial growth
: the secret of water
purification in antiquity. Dolara, P.; Arrigucci, S.; Cassetta, M. I.; Fallani,
S.; Novelli, A. International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents 2005 pp. 338-340

Antimicrobial
effects of wine on Escherichia coli O157:H7
and Salmonella typhimurium in
a model stomach system. Just, J. R.; Daeschel, M. A. Journal of Food Science
2003 Vol. 68 No. 1 pp. 285-290 

A nutritional
supplement formula for influenza A (H5N1) infection in humans
. Medical
Hypotheses 2006 Vol. 67 No. 3 pp. 578-587

2 thoughts on “Pass the Chalice?

  1. Hiro November 4, 2009 / 4:45 pm

    Well, i don’t think that wine from the bishops chalice is the common wy to get infected. Anyhow, i think there just is no real alternative to having a vaccination but…
    I just found this article on my most famous finance website.
    It’s about a fashionable way of fighting swine flu if you don’t want to wear those ugly white or greenish face masks…
    Maybe it can put a smile on your face in this uncertain times:
    http://www.finet.hk/mainsite/newscenter/PRNCN/20091103221627a871cdxprbgs.html

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s